skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Following the week's topic of discussion (religion & sexual morality), today's posting would entail Dionysus, the ancient Greek god of wine, the inspirer of ritual madness and ecstasy. He IS the major figure in Greek mythology. To the Romans he is Bacchus; the God of frenzy, patron deity of agriculture and theatre. So strong is his influence on mortals that there is a cult dedicated to him and each spring, they would celebrate in a festival for 5 whole days.
What interest me is philosophical and literary concept between Apollo and Dionysus. Apollo is the God of the Sun celebrating lightness, music, and poetry, while Dionysus is the God of wine, ecstasy and intoxication. Modern literary have contrasting concepts between Apollo and Dionysus - wholeness vs. individualism, light vs. darkness and civilization vs. primal nature. Interestingly, the ancient Greeks did not consider the two as opposites or rivals. It seems that modern Western philosophical and literary figures have used this concept to invoke in their own search of making sense of the world. One such figure, is Friedrich Nietzsche in his work The Birth of Tragedy whereby the tragic hero of the drama, the main protagonist, struggles to make order (Apollonian) of his unjust and chaotic (Dionysian) fate, though he dies unfulfilled in the end. Another leading figure is Ayn Rand for her best-selling novel, The Fountainhead - a classic for all Architects to read.
A character trait for an Apollonian:
Thinking, self-controlled, rational, logical, ordered, the dream state, principle of individuation, value for human order and culture, celebration of appearance/illusion, plastic & visual arts, human being(s) as artists.
A character trait for a Dionysian:
Feeling, passionate, irrational, instinctual, chaotic, state of intoxication, wholeness of existence, celebration of nature, brute realism & absurdity, music, human being(s) as the work and glorification of art.
In Sexual Personae by Camille Paglia, the two concepts is split into gender with Dionysian associated with females, wild/chaotic nature, and unconstrained sex/procreation, and Apollonian with males, clarity, rationality/reason, and solidity, along with the goal of oriented progress. I can just imagine the anger and hear the screaming feminist out there asking for my head! Ladies, before you start calling me names, Paglia is a woman. So please stand down! To her, she attributes the progress of civilization to males (Apollonian) revolting against the Dionysian forces of females. This chaotic state is overpowering and alluring at the same time, and the turn away from it towards socially ordered virtues accounts for the prevalence of asexuality and homosexuality in geniuses and in the most culturally prosperous places such as ancient Athens.
As much as I try to agree to Paglia, I think it's rather limiting to pigeon-hole gender in such a way. And I don't like pigeons. They are rats with wings especially the ones you get in Trafalgar Square. Awful creatures. Now, woodpigeon is another thing altogether - they are delicious!
Today is an important day. Firstly, it is Audrey's birthday and secondly, the Brunette is meeting me at my 'bridge'. Looks like our relationship have turned a new leaf. We are slowly and surely becoming attached to each other and surprisingly (what??), we both feel good (very very good in fact!) about it. Funny thing is that we are suddenly more aware of our 'similarity differences' a new term I've coined when it comes of integration. You know what, I'm sure I can explain this term better with Architecture. And I will do just that but I need to research the examples to illustrate the idea first. Wait for it...
Anyway, it is officially spring on Sunday. Hurrah!!! And like everything else in spring time, a new beginning has started for me and more projects to come for the studio. Like the Irish quote - If you don't sow in the spring, you'll not reap in the autumn. I'm optimistic that things are looking up from now on. Bring it on!
Happy Birthday Audrey!
What a day yesterday was! For the first time in 4 months, I've manage to sleep properly. I woke up on Monday after a leisurely 14 hours sleep! AMAZING! Luckily, I wasn't needed in the office and took my time. It was good to sleep but not so in terms of catching up with the day's work. Continuing my thoughts on Architectural theory, I've decided to include an excerpt from Bertrand Russell's, The Problems of Philosophy:
'Jeg er lei av å være som dette. Stadig opptatt, men i realiteten veldig mye alene. Deretter kommer noen som bryr seg om meg, push jeg henne unna. Hva er galt med meg? Er jeg redd for at jeg ikke vil ha noen nære i livet mitt? Kanskje, det er derfor jeg ikke kan være lykkelig. Sjansene kommer én gang, har dere å gripe øyeblikket, ellers vil den skli deg av og sitter du igjen med ubesvarte spørsmål. Jeg vet hun vil være å lese dette og jeg håper at hun vil forstå at jeg er et produkt av smertefulle erfaringer. Et produkt av tapte muligheter. Et produkt med konstant uro. Sist gang dette skjer, forlot jenta meg og det tok meg en stund å plukke opp bitene. Jeg tror ikke jeg kan klare det igjen. Jeg var fullstendig kaos. Hjertet er en skjør ting, og konstant arrdannelse leger ikke såret. Kanskje burde jeg bare spør og bekymring senere. Stille, jeg andre gjette meg og hvis jeg ser på meg selv nå, ville jeg ikke engang gi meg et annet blikk. Hvorfor skulle hun det? Nå that't sannheten. Jeg håper jeg blir bevist feil. Hvorfor blir jeg tiltrukket av henne? Vel, andre enn hennes fysiske attributter, er det hele uanstrengt. Jeg håper bare at hun føler det samme.'
**Translated: 'Is there any knowledge in the world which is so certain that no reasonable man could doubt it? This question, which at first sight might not seem difficult, is really one of the most difficult that can be asked. When we have realized the obstacles in the way of a straightforward and confident answer, we shall be launched on the study of philosophy, for philosophy is merely the attempt to answer such ultimate questions, not carelessly and dogmatically, as we do in ordinary life and even in the sciences, but critically, after exploring all that makes such questions puzzling, and after realizing all the vagueness and confusion that inderlie our ordinary ideas. In daily life, we assume as certain many things which, on a closer scrutiny, are found to be full of apparent contradictions that only a great amount of thought enables us to know what it is that we really may believe.'
What does this all mean? Well, I'm in the process of interpreting a public space in the Spanish capital. On first glance, the site itself presents various contradictions. Urban, local, decay, homeless, elevation, disjointed, peace, religion, crusade are just some of the words that describe it. The site is complex and difficult. Compared to the other districts, its soul stems from the residence as well as the homeless - a very rare situation. My approach has change tremendously since I started, from 'tidying' to 'rearranging' and finally, not to interfere. Homelessness is often followed closely with stigma but what we don't realise is that, there is a surge in Middle-Class educated homeless people and the recent study made by London boroughs supports this. This trend is also visible cities like New York. People who never thought that they'll slide into homelessness are staring it in the face. We can't keep categorising them into boxes and place them accordingly. We can't pretend to think that we know what is best for them. We can't keep doing the same mistakes. So, the question now is, does all this urban 'tidying' and 'rearranging' is helping anyone or is it to stroke our own professional egos?
Yippee!! In my mind, I think we've made some progress but I'm not so sure if the Brunette (schauen Sie vorsichtig, und ich bin sicher, dass Sie es finden werden. nichts ist, was es scheint) thinks the same. Emotions were running high. People say don't drink-dial or drink-text but honestly, emotional texting is even worse. The wording just gets tangled up in a mess and the message becomes a battle ground. I misfired a few and got pinned down with heavy artillery fire. But unlike modern warfare, a ceasefire was reached after a peace dialogue. And like all peace talks, the continual negotiation is expected before an agreement is reached. If 1 is war and 10 is peace, I believe we are at 4. Oh no!!
'Unlike the necessity of mere building, the non-necessity of Architecture is undissociable from architectural histories, theories and other precedents. These bonds enhance pleasure. The most excessive passion is always methodical. In such moments of intense desire, organisation invades pleasure to such an extent that it is not
always possible to distinguish the organising constraints from the erotic matter. For example, the Marquis de Sade's heroes enjoyed confining their victims in the strictest convents before mis-treating them according to rules carefully laid down in a precise and obsessive logic.
Similarly, the game of Architecture is an intricate play with rules that one may accept or reject. Indifferently called Systeme des Beaux-Arts or Modern Movement precepts, this pervasive network of binding laws entangles architectural design. These rules, like so many knots that cannot be untied, are generally a paralyzing constraint. When manipulated, however, they have the erotic significance of bondage. To differentiate between rules or ropes is irrelevant here. What matters is that there is no simple bondage technique: the more the numerous and sophisticated the restraints, the greather the pleasure.'